It’s OK, no one died, says PR-type

In a bizarrely inaccurate statement, Owen Roberts, a public relations-type for the University of Guelph in Canada, wrote in the local paper on Monday after his latest junket to a conference for agricultural journalists in Japan that,

"The Japanese government is trying to solve the food safety and self-sufficiency problems in one clean sweep by convincing consumers that the only safe food product is locally grown. Unfortunately they’ve experienced a few hiccups along the way — an E. coli outbreak in 1996, a foot and mouth problem in 2000, BSE in 2001, and an "inappropriate" food labelling problem in 2002.

"Even so, nobody in Japan ever died from any of these scares. So why are the Japanese so paranoid?"

Huh?

In the summer of 1996, over 9,500 Japanese, largely schoolchildren, were stricken with E. coli O157:H7 and 12 were killed, most likely linked to the consumption of raw radish sprouts.

In July, 2000, an outbreak of Staphylococcus aureu in Snow Brand milk sickened 14,700 after workers failed to clean factory pipes for weeks.

In Aug. 2002, five elderly patients died from E. coli O157:H7 linked to food served at a nursing home.

There have been dozens of other outbreaks of foodborne illness  in Japan — and in every other country — involving not only death but countless untold illnesses. Healthy skepticism seems warranted. Especially of PR-types.

Indiana, Illinois and E. coli O157:H7

The Effingham County Health Department in Illinois is investigating at least six confirmed cases of E. coli O157, all linked to eating at El Rancherito restaurant in Effingham at I-57 and I-70. The health department says the restaurant is cooperating and has been closed since Thursday.

And in neighboring Indiana, two students have been confirmed with E. coli O157:H7 and several others are showing symptoms. Hundreds of elementary students were apparently sent home with warning letters on Friday.

One of Seattle attorney Bill Marler’s many blogs, http://www.about-ecoli.com/, has lots of background information on E. coli.

But it’s local, it must be safe

Hawaii’s Department of Health was cited as reporting earlier this month that four tourists and four others on Kaua’i in March were most likely infected by eating contaminated lettuce from a Kaua’i farm, where heavy rains and flooding had carried E. coli O157 from a cattle pasture onto the lettuce patch.

The story notes
that health investigators took DNA from the disease organisms in patients, and were able to determine that the strain of E. coli O157 bacteria in all the victims had the same DNA fingerprint.

Janice Okubo, public information officer for the state Department of Health, was quoted as saying,

"It was determined that one item, locally produced lettuce, was common to at least one restaurant eaten at by each case during their probable exposure."

Sorry, Scottish bureaucrats aren’t that into you either

As the latest E. coli O157 outbreak ravages Scotland, including one death and seven ill linked to cold cuts, Professor Hugh Pennington today said there was no excuse for allowing contaminated cold meat to be sold, after lessons were learned from a major outbreak in Lanarkshire 10 years ago.

"We had hoped we’d seen the last of outbreaks associated with butchers. I think there really is no excuse for it. We know how to prevent it. … There is no excuse for putting your customers at risk. Undoubtedly this outbreak will be down to human error – either someone doing something they shouldn’t or not doing something they should."

Meanwhile, an editorial in The Herald has questioned why there appears to have been a delay of several days before information regarding the outbreak was made public, echoing my comments about Canadian officials,

"There is always a danger that premature announcements provoke unnecessary panic. However, public protection must outweigh the danger of spreading unwarranted alarm. Vulnerable people and their carers have a right to expect the enforcement of basic hygiene in the handling of food and a right to know promptly when things go wrong."