Salmonella in the sand: blame the bandicoots

Last weekend I had the chance to renew my friendship with Sam from Sydney.

She’s the communications manager for the New South Wales Food Authority (the state where Sydney is located in Australia), She booked an inexpensive room for me and Chapman and his only girlfriend one ANZAC day back in 2002.

This is our respective gangs last weekend at Bondi Beach in Sydney (right, exactly as shown; I wore shorts, the others were ridiculous). Amy now gets it when I say, Bondi is awesome.

A short boat ride north of Bondi is Manley beach, which has been plagued with Salmonella in the sand for years.

In May, 2008, children’s playgrounds were closed on Sydney’s Northern Beaches after a rare form of salmonella, paratyphi B var java, normally linked to tropical fish, sickened 23 toddlers. The sand was replaced at a cost of $140,000 but subsequent testing showed the same Salmonella had returned.

Over three years later, and once again, part of the popular children’s playground at Winnererremy Bay was closed after testing revealed the presence of Salmonella bacteria in the surface bark.

Three children were taken to hospital with severe diarrhea, vomiting and stomach pain during the gastro outbreak on the northern beaches between 2007 and 2009. A further 72 people, mostly young children, became ill.

Health types reported today the cause was long-nosed bandicoots pooing in the sandpits.

At the time, health authorities could not determine the source of the salmonella. There were theories it came from dirty nappies, cockroaches or the feces of rats, ducks and ibis.

In a paper published last month in the U.S. Centers for Disease Control’s journal Emerging Infectious Diseases, investigators from NSW Health said children ate the sand carrying the bacteria. The bacterium has been traditionally associated with imported ornamental fish.

The investigators found that one central depot that delivers sand to playgrounds was a ”common factor” in all contaminated playgrounds and that the depot was situated in a ”wild bushland setting.’

Most places in Australia are a wild bushland setting.

During tests of fecal and cloacal samples from 261 animals, the investigators found the salmonella strain in ducks, rats, possums and a dog, but by far ”the most were from a marsupial species native to the local area, the long-nosed bandicoot”, the paper said.

”Although sand from the central depot was a common factor in all contaminated playgrounds where case-patients contracted the illness, the infection source for this facility remains unknown,” the paper said. ”It was located in a wild bushland setting, and it is feasible that transmission of the bacterium from local wildlife occurred.”

The authors wrote that their study identified accidental sand ingestion as a ”previously unrecognised pathway for humans acquiring illness caused by S. enterica var. Java.”

Pink slime saga boosts Australian beef exports

 Like mad cow disease, although on a much smaller scale, Australian cattle exporters are reaping the benefits of the pink slime controversy in the U.S.

AAP reports beef and veal exports to the U.S. are expected to increase by 28 per cent to 205,000 tonnes in 2011/12, the Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics and Sciences (ABARES) said in its June quarter commodities report.

ABARES attributed U.S. demand for imported beef to reduced cattle slaughter and an ongoing fall-out over reports in March that 70 per cent of ground beef sold in American supermarkets contained pink slime – a cheap meat filler treated with an antibacterial agent.

But beef exports to Indonesia are likely to fall by about 27 per cent to 530,000 head during the same period, after footage of cattle being treated inhumanely at local slaughter houses was aired on ABC television.

Public outcry over the footage led to Australian live exports to Indonesia being suspended for a month.

The live trade resumed after stronger auditing requirements were put in place, but exports have struggled to recover, with Indonesia now pushing for self-sufficiency in the beef market.

Apparently not another raw egg outbreak in Australia

This is why I put question marks on some headlines: because something doesn’t seem quite right.

A story dated June 7, 2012 and published by ThePoultrySite – my favorite read while exfoliating in the bath – had this lede:

AUSTRALIA – Currently the NSW Food Authority is investigating 49 cases of Salmonella poisoning, suspected to be from consuming foods containing raw egg.

I dutifully blogged the news, not so much the research, but that there was yet another outbreakof salmonella in eggs which, given the track-record in Australia, would be far from surprising.

An answer arrived a week later in the form of an e-mail from the New South Wales Food Authority: “The information the Poultry CRC used was actually from a media alert posted on our website in 2007 – http://foodauthority.nsw.gov.au/news/alerts-recalls/alert-eggs-and-food-poisoning/.

Oops. Sorry. A table of raw-egg related outbreaks in Australia is available at http://bites.ksu.edu/raw-egg-related-outbreaks-australia.

Blaming consumers, Australia edition: taxpayer money to make people feel guilty about foodborne illness that wasn’t their fault

Bad food safety information, like bacteria, has no respect for geographic boundaries.

Food safety isn’t simple; people argue about specifics all the time. But failing to acknowledge uncertainties, doubts or errors while making proclamations from on public relations high undermines the credibility of the message and the messenger.

Marnie McKimmie of The West Australian wrote a piece a couple of weeks ago that, in one special synthesis, contains a greatest hits of microbial food safety myths.

Juliana Madden, executive director of the Food Safety Information Council, Australia’s version of the equally tragic FightBac and other consumer education campaigns, shares these gems:

"You can be sloppy peeling the carrots if you are going to bake them, but if you are going to stir fry or have salads then you have to be a lot more careful because that little bit of dirt on the outside can still be there and can contain all sorts of things but particularly E. coli, which is one of the big ones and is just hideously awful.”

Any raw food can be contaminated. An outbreak of E. coli O157:H7 last year in the U.K. sickened 250 and killed one. Best guess was messy handling of raw potatoes and leeks. Carrots are the same. They’re grown in soil. Things poop on soil, and water with poop runs through soil. Careful with those carrot peels.

"The German bean sprouts outbreak was so unfortunate because it was a perfect storm. Those sprouts had actually been treated as properly as they could have been in regards to the regulations but there were two mutations – one made the E.coli a lot more toxic and the other made the E.coli a lot stickier and therefore difficult to wash off."

The contamination was probably in the seed, like in so many other sprouts outbreaks (a table is available at http://bites.ksu.edu/sprouts-associated-outbreaks). No amount of washing would have prevented the outbreak. And mutations happen all the time.

“Always wash pre-washed green vegetables. Despite what the label advises, these must always be washed again at home to reduce the risk of food poisoning from bacteria such as listeria,” warned Sophie Williamson, WA Health Department food unit acting manager.

Researchers concluded in a 2007 review that additional washing of pre-washed salads would increase the food safety risk because of potential cross-contamination in food service and home kitchens. As Don Zink of the U.S. Food and Drug Administration told USA Today last year, bagged lettuce and spinach were already washed in a sanitizing solution at the packing plant and it was probably a lot cleaner than your kitchen. Microorganisms bond to the surface of the food item. "You are not going to rinse them off, it simply won’t happen, they cannot be washed off.”

Or, as I said, All washing might do is "remove the snot that some 3-year-old blew onto the food at the grocery store.” Washing "lowers the pathogen count a little, but not to safe levels if it’s contaminated."

People can have their preferences – back it up with data.

“Bean sprouts. A high-risk food that must be washed thoroughly, Ms Williamson said.”

Again, washing does almost nothing except make people feel good. The U.S National Advisory Committee on Microbiological Criteria for Foods figured this out in 1999.

“Chicken. Still not enough families were ensuring it was cooked until the pink in the middle disappeared and the liquid clear, warned Ms Williamson.”

Color is a terrible indicator. Using a tip-sensitive digital thermometer is the only way to tell if food has reached a safe temperature. Even some Aussies are warming to the idea of thermometers.

Who funds this Food Safety Information Council? See for yourself at foodsafety.asn.au.

Listeria in Pauls Smarter White Milk, Australia

Parmalat Australia Ltd has recalled Pauls Smarter White Milk (1L) from Woolworths, Coles, BP Service Stations and smaller independent outlets in NT due to Listeria Monocytogenes contamination. Listeria may cause illness in pregnant women and their unborn babies, the elderly and people with low immune systems.

For further information, please contact Parmalat Australia Ltd on 1800 676 961.

Another raw egg outbreak in Australia?

Wait, what?

As I was reading today’s news from ThePoultrySite while exfoliating in the bath, I noticed The New South Wales Food Authority, the state where Sydney is, is investigating 49 cases of Salmonella poisoning, suspected to be from consuming foods containing raw egg.

The rest of the story wasn’t about people barfing, it was about a Poultry CRC project examining how defects in shell quality and structure may increase the risk of bacteria on the outside of the egg shell entering the egg. This research is being led by Associate Professor Julie Roberts at the University of New England in Armidale. ??By investigating the incidence (and significance) of minor defects in the ultrastructure of the egg shell, such as translucency, the project aims to quantify the ease with which bacteria causing food-borne illness are able to penetrate the egg shell. This involves a number of research approaches; traditional measures of egg quality, cuticle staining, shell ultrastructure assessment and microbial studies.

But what about the sick people? No other public reporting, nothing on the NSW Food Authority web site, nothing, even though Australia still has a serious egg problem.

A table of raw-egg related outbreaks in Australia (thanks Gonzalo and Sol) is available at http://bites.ksu.edu/raw-egg-related-outbreaks-australia.

Melbourne woman critical after eating mushrooms

A Melbourne woman is critically ill after eating a toxic death cap mushroom.

Six months after a similar outbreak in a Canberra restaurant killed two and sickened one, Australian health authorities are again warning people not to pick their own mushrooms as recent weather conditions have created the ideal environment for the poisonous fungi.

Austin Hospital emergency department director Dr Fergus Kerr said death cap mushroom poisoning is particularly hard to detect as the more severe symptoms may not appear until a day or two after ingestion.

He said poisoning by death cap mushrooms had a mortality rate of about 50 per cent and urged people to only eat commercially farmed mushrooms.

Memo to Australian retailers: provide sanitizing wipes in stores or pay to clean my shorts

This is going to be transformed into dinner in about 12 hours, traditional comfort food as the people of Brisbane bundle up with lows as low as 59F and highs of only 69F with rain (people are dressed like it was Feb. in Saskatoon).

But when I picked the bird out of the cooler case yesterday, blood ran down my hand. I looked for something to help clean up the mess and could only find my shorts.

The same thing happened a few weeks ago with some marked-down packaged chicken pieces. I happened to pick a checkout aisle that was being manned by the manager. I asked Mr. Megalomart Manager if he had something form me to wipe my hands on.

Nope.

I asked about the bloody drippings now on the checkout conveyor. He looked around but couldn’t find the sanitizing solution he insisted was at every checkout.

I said, in the U.S. and Canada, it has become routine to find disposable sanitizing wipes not only near the meat counter, but any raw product such as produce, along with a variety of contraptions and wipes for sanitizing shopping carts.

Manager thought the wipes were a decent idea; they had a weekly food safety meeting and he’d bring it up with corporate.

Corporate trashed the idea because of cost and waste.

Something to keep in mind next time a vp of something proclaims, “food safety is our top priority.”

Meat gets around; Australian beef implicated in South Carolina E. coli positive sample

Australians don’t take kindly to suggestions their beef may have E. coli.

A Japanese chain serving raw beef tried the tactic in an E. coli O157:H7 outbreak last year that sickened 20 people, and now a positive sample in South Carolina – no people sick – has triggered diverse responses.

On May18, 2012, two South Carolina companies, Lancaster Frozen Foods and G&W Inc. announced they were recalling nearly 7,000 pounds of ground beef after a state testing program found an E. coli O157 positive sample (there was no mention of a possible connection with the E. coli O157:H7 outbreak in early May at a restaurant in South Carolina that sickened 11 people, but outbreaks do focus the attention of public health folks).

The Charlotte Observer reported the SC meat originated from an Australian packing plant, and that the companies no longer buy beef from the Australian company.

A few days later the story popped up throughout Australia, with meat types insisting the meat was safe and noting that more than 70 Australian plants are certified by the U.S. Department of Agriculture to export meat and poultry.

Australian TV got into the scrum, declaring that up to 13 Australian shipments of contaminated meat have been rejected by USDA in the past year, including nine loads of mutton contaminated with feces and one load because of veterinary drug residues.

Meat and Livestock Australia Ltd. said in January that one of the "major hurdles for Australian exports to the U.S. in 2012" would be increased non-O157 E. coli testing requirements. MLA estimated Australia’s beef exports to the U.S. in 2011 were valued at A$744 million.

The U.S. is Australia’s second largest export market for beef and its largest export market for lamb.

Seek and ye shall find: increased testing means increased positives, and it’s going to take diplomatic skills and data to better understand what a positive means.

In the short-term, blame the foreigners will remain politically appealing: Australia does it, U.S. does it, Canada does it, every country in Europe does it. 

Clean up the spilled gravy or get sued if someone slips

A far north Queensland woman is seeking more than half a million dollars in compensation after slipping on gravy at a bowls club (that’s what they call lawn bowling in Australia).

Eeva (Eeva) Johanna Watchers, 35, filed documents in the Cairns District Court this week saying she had fallen near a buffet at the Edmonton Bowls Club in July 2008 and dislocated her right knee.?? Ms Watchers says the slip left her with permanent knee damage and she’s been unable to return to work.