Amy Hubbell

About Amy Hubbell

Lecturer in French at the University of Queensland, food safety conscious person, and spectator of terrible reality cooking shows Download C.V. »

Poop in the Field, circa January 2007

This video is a product of the Food Safety Family Swingers and it exemplifies our attempts at getting the message out using our creative resources. Doug and I wrote the song together while thinking about the spinach E. coli O157:H7 outbreak in the fall of 2006 and what caused it. It really boils down to our favorite message: Don’t eat poop.

Poop in the Field Lyrics
POOP IN THE FIELD (YOU GIVE SPINACH A BAD NAME)

A convenient product is what you sell
you promise me freshness then put me through hell
diarrhea’s got a hold on me
when my washroom’s a prison I can’t break free

Whoa — the bag’s the smoking gun, yeah
Whoa — now I’ve got the runs
No one can save me the damage is done!

Poop in the field, manure’s to blame
You give spinach a bad name
I ate it fresh and it gave me pain
You give spinach… a bad name.

Leafy greens touched my lips
Blood black stool on my fingertips
Pre-washed marketing is just a lie
‘Cause ready to eat means ready to die!

Whoa — the bag’s the smoking gun, yeah
Whoa — now I’ve got the runs
No one can save me, the damage is done!

Poop in the field, manure’s to blame
You give spinach a bad name
I ate it fresh, it gave me pain
You give spinach a bad name…

Restaurant Wars

In last night’s episode of Bravo’s Top Chef, the winning team used a meat thermometer. While this is a rarity within the celebrity chef circle, at least based on what we see in the final cut, it’s the second time I’ve seen one used on Top Chef this season (both times the chefs became winners, and both times they were cooking lamb). Last night Quatre’s sous-chef Howie wielded the same sort of digital tip-sensitive thermometer that we use at home. He had the unsliced chops, on their side, and inserted the thermometer into the middle of the meat. (Of course, this week the cheftestants also had head judge Chef Tom Colicchio watching them in the kitchen.) While Howie’s former nemesis, Joey, called his chops, “Typical Howie, undercooked!” the judges said they were cooked beautifully and perfectly. They had ordered their chops rare.

For those of you interested in trying this at home, there is no simple answer for finding the correct temperature of perfect-rare and safe lamb chops. Some recipe sites I consulted recommended a temperature of 125 F-130 degrees for medium rare. However, according to USDA for beef, veal and lamb (steaks, roasts and chops), medium rare is at 145 °F and medium is 160 °F.

Hormel proposes the following:

“Traditional guidelines state that lamb cooked very rare, rare, medium rare, or medium should have an internal temperature ranging between 115ºF to 145°F. With increased concern over bacteria that may be present in the internal portions of lamb, it is now recommended that whole lamb cuts be cooked to a final internal temperature (after resting) of not less than 145°F.”

While Howie may have hit the right temperature to please the judges, no one knows what his magic thermometer reading actually was. Still, I’m glad to see a thermometer once again on the show, used correctly (i.e inserted into the thickest portion of the meat), and this time for more than a second.

Noble Rot: Sounds hot, but is it safe?

huitlacocheIn Gourmet magazine’s TV series Diary of a Foodie, episode 15 focuses on the good molds used in developing certain foods. I recorded the show last night to find out if any food safety would be mentioned, and we watched it today while eating Doug’s homemade baguettes and some mold-covered camembert made in the U.S. with pasteurized milk.

Narrator: “The smell of rot – that ripe funk of a humid cellar – is heaven to any cheese affineur.”  (Affinage is the process of aging or ripening of cheese).

Taking us to the Parisian cheese shop of famed fromagère Marie-Anne Cantin, the first host says, “Mold is like alchemy in food.” It changes food “magically.” Yes, mold is good for a lot of things. It does participate in some magical cheese making. Cantin explains the varieties of penicillium and how they are introduced to a different cheeses. The host says that mold protects the cheese so “bad things don’t get into it. So it’s actually good for you.”

This is all fascinating, but the safety of it is not addressed. Instead the show focuses on issues of taste and legality. In the U.S. raw milk cheeses have to be aged at least 60 days, because, as Cantin says in untranslated French, “Americans are a little afraid.” The host comforts the viewers saying that serious foodies are trying to change this law.

The show goes on to explore the Botrytis grape mold used in making great Sauterne and other dessert wines, homemade yogurt made from a 19th century culture at the Schimmel Bakery (Narrator: “Edible bacteria adds delicious pungent flavor and some are quite simply good for you”), how rotten potatoes can be used to make bread with the “most old-fashioned flavor,” and  … rotten corn.

Narrator: “While some will scream ‘health risk’ at the sight of huitlacoché’s mushrooming black spores, in Mexico these infected corn kernels are considered a delicacy.”

At Santa Monica’s Border Grill, huitlacoché it’s used in quesadillas for the “adventurous” crowd. Huitlachoché is the mold growing on corn kernels. The kernels blow up into a mushrooms that are cut off the cob, chopped up, and cooked. The chefs say it’s sweet and smoky tasting. According to one of the chef’s theories, “The more different things you eat, the healthier you’ll be.”

The only food safety advice comes across quite casually towards the end of the show in another cheese and sausage shop that tries to import foods unknown in the U.S. White fluffy mold on the sausage is OK, green or black mold on air-dried beef is bad.

Anyway – mold is everywhere. “It’s natural,” says Cantin.

Mold may be natural, but some of it, can make you sick. Mycotoxins, poisonous toxins that can make you sick, grow on grain, nuts, celery, grape juice, apples, and other produce. Aflotoxin, a type of mycotoxin that can grow on peanuts and corn, is cancer causing. According to the USDA website, “The U.S. Food and Drug Administration and the USDA monitor peanuts and field corn for aflatoxin and can remove any food or feed with unacceptable levels of it.”

Molds can cause allergic and respiratory problems, and the USDA advises not to buy moldy foods, “Examine food well before you buy it. Check food in glass jars, look at the stem areas on fresh produce, and avoid bruised produce. Notify the store manager about mold on foods!” The USDA site http://www.fsis.usda.gov/Fact_Sheets/Molds_On_Food/index.asp has an excellent chart about which foods, when moldy, should be discarded and which can be spared. It also explains why.

In addition, Louisiana State University advises, “Mushrooms in lawns and moldy foods can be health hazards for your dogs, according to LSU AgCenter veterinarian Dr. Steve Nicholson.”

It’s safest to know your molds, the good and the bad, as well as their associated risks before you eat them or feed them to your children or dogs.

Butter, the new cheese

I love butter and I loved it long before living in Brittany where they claim to make the best butter in the world, naturally flavored with sea salt. It was in France that I learned to eat butter with my Roquefort cheese. I’m salivating at the very decadent thought… But after turning 30 I sadly had to slow down on my intake as my metabolism started to  churn instead of speed through fat.

Now it seems that North American foodies have caught on and butter is the new cheese. According to the July 25 Globe and Mail, “Long overlooked by gourmets, butter is being transformed from a supper table staple into Quebec’s latest delicacy.” Gilles Jourdenais, who owns the Fromagerie Atwater – the largest cheese wholesaler in Canada, says that “Quebec’s nascent artisanal butter scene is where cheese was 15 years ago, when no one believed local products could rival European imports.”

In Quebec, farmers are pasteurizing their fresh milk in small batches and at lower temperatures to “preserve herbaceous hints in the milk and fullness in the cream.” Unlike France that allows consumers to purchase raw milk butters with very high fat contents, “Canadian law restricts producers from serving raw milk butters, so they are required to pasteurize the milk.”

Maybe on our way through the Quebec countryside to the Laurentians in the next few weeks we’ll make a stop at a local creamery. I’m all in favor of the small-batch low-heat pasteurized butter, as long as the care put into it includes microbiologically safe practices. It’s like buttah. My 30-something metabolism will handle it.

The Summer of Dangerously Global Food?

Recently news sources have focused on the question, “Where does your food come from?” Everyone’s on board with the query. The Topeka, KS evening news ran a local version of the story and our own Manhattan Mercury ran its take on it, too (see “Grocer providing a market for agriculture industry” on July 22, 2007). In the last two weeks Doug has been quoted in the Washington Post, the L.A. Times and twice in USAToday about imported food from China.

I can’t help but wonder if this is like the media induced “Summer of Shark Attacks” or the summer after that when the focus was on high profile kidnappings. In both of those instances it was proven that the number of shark attacks and kidnappings were no higher than normal. The media had simply found a way to highlight specific subjects and heighten American viewers’ concerns on the topic. Are we suddenly so bored that we are shocked that our food comes from global sources when just a few weeks ago we ate without a care that our cereal was composed of ingredients from 9 different countries? Or is there reason to be worried after recent problems with Chinese ingredients in pet food and toothpaste?

From the July 19 USA Today:

While it may be "psychologically comforting to blame others," what the U.S. needs is farm-to-fork food safety, said Douglas Powell, director of the International Food Safety Network at Kansas State University. "Imports are a problem. So is food produced in the U.S. One should not distract from another."

Food, whether it’s of the trendy local variety, or if it comes from around the globe, presents special concerns. No matter its provenance, we need to be vigilant, because every bite we take of uncooked (or improperly cooked and handled food) is an act of faith.

Riding in Cars

Doug and I just returned from a 10-day road trip to Florida and back to Kansas with three of his teenage girls. The journey to Florida was reasonably broken up into segments and we chose towns, hotels, and restaurants that would accommodate our diverse interests and needs. On the trip back we started talking about the next time we do this trip, when it’s just the two of us, we can drive down with our two dogs and rent a house near a beach on the Gulf somewhere.

When I read yesterday’s St. Louis Post-Dispatch story, “City aldermen loosen leash on dogs dining at restaurants” in FSnet, I added St. Louis to the list of places we can stop on that next trip. Taking a road trip with dogs, like kids, means special consideration about where and how long to stop, and what kinds of towns, hotels, and restaurants we patronize – especially in the summer when it is dangerous to leave the puppies in the car. Cities committed to rules for safe doggy dining make it easier for us to keep our dogs safe while we dine on the road.

Top Chefs… Stick it in

Last night on Bravo’s Top Chef, Micah got eliminated for her bad-tasting but healthy meatloaf. Last week, Micah caught my attention as she used a meat thermometer in the barbeque elimination challenge. She came in the top three for her perfectly grilled lamb chops.

This is the same show that has had openly sick (or at least nauseated) chefs cooking anyway because they didn’t want to be kicked out of the competition (they wouldn’t get work in Michigan, where the state has proposed that someone with vomiting, diarrhea or a sore throat with fever could not return until 24 hours after the symptoms are gone).

And last night when the oven wasn’t working and Cheftestant Sara M’s chicken didn’t get done, she handpicked and served the pieces that looked cooked… no meat thermometer in sight, at least to the viewers.

Although Micah’s gone now, hats off to her.  Often depressed and crying, missing her daughter, Micah still had the presence of mind to stick in the meat thermometer to check the internal temperature of her barbecued meat. Whether she did it for accuracy or safety, Micah’s choice to use a thermometer stood out. How often do you see one on a TV cooking show? Perhaps the climate on the reality cooking circuit will change.

In 2004, Doug’s laboratory reported that, based on 60 hours of detailed viewing of television cooking shows, an unsafe food handling practice occurred about every four minutes, and that for every safe food handling practice observed, they observed 13 unsafe practices. The most common errors were inadequate hand washing and cross-contamination between raw and ready-to-eat foods.

Hey, reality cooking show producers: serve up another helping of food safety.

More Camembert Quandries

The N.Y. Times is reporting this morning that, citing health concerns, the two companies, Lactalis and the Isigny Sainte-Mère cooperative, which together made 90 percent of the traditional raw milk Camembert in Normandy, began earlier this year to treat the milk used for most of those cheeses.

In doing so, they were forced to sacrifice their Appellation d’Origine Contrôlée  or, A.O.C., status, the first time in French history that Camembert producers voluntarily did so. But they also have asked the French governmental food board to grant that status to their new Camemberts, arguing that the processing they use — either filtering or gently heating the milk — does not sacrifice the traditional taste and character of the cheese.

Mr. Durand and his supporters beg to differ, claiming that the move is a ploy by the dairy giants to make more cheese and profits while destroying a crucial part of French heritage. If the companies’ petition is granted, they argue, raw milk cheese would be threatened.

Is Camembert in jeopardy? This week my French "maman" went to the market and verified that Lepetit, one of the brands affected by the Isigny/Lactilis decision to quit using raw milk in their Camembert, is indeed, no longer putting lait cru cheese on the shelves.  What’s interesting, though, is that they still have the "moulé à la louche" or ladle-formed indication on the box. This is one of the traditional Camembert making methods that was said to be in jeopardy (see "Cheese Culture"). 

In fact, if Mr. Durand, as described in today’s N.Y. Times article, is the only one left in Normandy who makes traditional Camembert … does that mean the French don’t really care as much about the traditional cheesemaking process as having inexpensive and easily accessible cheese?

Evidence suggests “cheese culture” (or if H. prefers, the cultural approach to cheese) is changing in France.  Our neighbor Jean-Claude in Maubuisson, France, apologized profusely to us as he set out his cheese plate after the main course, saying that he should have provided a better combination of soft and hard cheeses, cow and sheep’s milk, etc. When we reciprocated dinner and put out our cheese platter, he commented on how well chosen our cheese variety was – even though I managed to forget a hard cheese for the selection. These details used to be an essential part of dining etiquette in France, but today they are only traditional suggestions. Jean-Claude said his mother always told him that it was good to take only three cheeses, not more. He’s nearly 60 now, and remembers the lessons he learned, but he does not honor them like the religion they once were.

If companies want to mass produce their cheese, and market it in countries like the U.S. with its strict cheese rules (and where we don’t really have a cultural approach to cheese unless we live in Wisconsin or Vermont), then these companies do need to think about the safety of consumers. Whether safety is a byproduct of mass marketing or if it is influenced by a culture that is less tolerant of losing small children to lait cru Camembert doesn’t really seem to be the issue. The fact is, the change has been made. The impact will be felt, and other large cheese companies will have to decide if they will follow suit.

Mr. Durand will likely continue providing to his niche markets, and if he wants to practice good marketing, he may come grow his client base due to these changes.

Weeds

The name of a popular series on Showtime, Weeds, is also now becoming a popular part of haute cuisine in France. On June 7, 2007, on France 2’s “Envoyé special” (a show like 20/20 or 60-minutes in the U.S.), one of the segments was dedicated to the use of “herbes sauvages” or wild herbs in France’s top 3-star restaurants. The reporters followed a member of the Radio France chorus who picked weeds right in Paris, tasted and explained them, and then carried them to her favorite 3-star chef. After demonstrating how fine tastes can come from these strangely exotic yet common weeds, they were off to a farm in Brittany where one woman specializes in growing weeds. She used to grow grains but when she recognized the profitability of this niche market, she switched. Her farm now has an annual income of over €200,000 a year – for picking, packing, selling and shipping dandelion leaves and the like. There’s even a workshop led in Switzerland where you can go around picking wild herbs in the mountains all day and then come back and learn how to make them into pesto and flan. Not to fear, the French are well aware that some herbs are toxic. But they put it into perspective: we eat potatoes, but the leaves are dangerous to eat. Same with rhubarb – never eat the leaves. One man was ready to pop a “bouton d’or” (buttercup) into his mouth when his instructor yelled out, “Non!” The 3-star chef assured that when he had questions about an item, he contacted his friend the horticulturalist to be on the safe side.

This program brought two things to my attention. The French think that the dangerous side of food is sexy, but there’s more to food safety than avoiding inherently toxic foods. At no point did anyone discuss the conditions in which the herbs were grown. As Doug and I wrote in our doggy-dining article … there is dog poop all over Paris and the rest of France. If there’s a patch of grass somewhere, it’s very likely that a cat or dog (or human) is also using this spot for relief. That’s quite a lot less sexy to think about than the perils of eating such refined foods as weeds. One aspiring chef said that everyone made fun of her … everyone asked her the same questions about knowing if the weeds were dangerous or not. She never mentioned if she thought that dog, cat, mouse, bird, or turtle poop might be on the herbs she’s putting primarily into fresh salads and uncooked sauces.

Cheese Culture: I can’t believe it’s not Camembert

I’ve often been called a cultural snob, primarily for my love of French food. Caring about taste and presentation is something I learned in France, from the French (and not from my parents in Missouri who cook what they call survival food). As Doug and I are traveling in France, we have picked up different kinds of cheeses. In our refrigerator right now there are two types of Camembert: the Monoprix brand that we picked up 10 days ago in Toulouse, and the Reflets de France brand (produced by Laiterie St Hilaire de Briouze) that we bought about 5 days ago in our small village’s supermarket.  In the store I pointed out to Doug that this one was made with lait cru – raw milk. I’m not a purist when it comes to French cheeses, and neither is Doug, but we thought it might be interesting to try something “authentic.”

Now every time we open the fridge it stinks so bad from the lait cru cheese we want to pass out. But there is no question which cheese we are eating faster (and not just to get the stink out): the Monoprix pasteurized cheese is resting in the back of the fridge while we eat up the raw milk Camembert. (Incidentally, we’ve both been suffering from frequent trips to the bathroom and trying to figure out what we’ve eaten recently that would bring on such rumbling in our bowels and stinking up the bathroom nearly as much as the fridge.)

In yesterday’s news, two of France’s (and thus the world’s) top lait cru Camembert producers, Lactalis and Isigny-Sainte-Mère, announced that they are forgoing the status of “Appellation d’Origine Contrôlée” and switching to cheese made exclusively with heat-treated micro-filtered milk (not quite pasteurized but still an affront to purists).

Lactilis’ spokesperson, Luc Morelon said that although they recognize the importance of Camembert traditions, they’re making the change “[b]ecause consumer safety is paramount, and we cannot guarantee it 100 per cent. We cannot accept the risk of seeing our historic brands disappearing because of an accident in production." In response to his critics Morelon added, “I don’t want to risk sending any more children to hospital. It’s as simple as that." Others believe that Lactilis simply cannot produce the quantities they want and keep using raw milk. According to the Telegraph, Lactilis’ and Isigny’s decision to opt out has now put pressure on the AOC to accept pasteurized milk. It all boils down to business.

While the French worry about the future of Camembert and other cheeses made from raw milk, I applaud the company for understanding that an unsafe cheese can harm the culture of Camembert more than using heated milk might.

I like having a choice to buy raw milk or processed cheese as I wish, but I understand the risks involved. I also still eat sushi and would likely still dip my finger in raw cake-batter or cookie dough. But when producers are responsible for the safety of thousands, if not millions, of consumers who do not know that what they’re eating might kill them, they need to assess the risks, take measures to prevent them, and in doing so, ensure a culture of safe food.