25 sick, up from 13; Salmonella linked to homemade unpasteurized fresh cheese in Minn

At least 25 Minnesotans have been sickened with salmonellosis linked to eating a raw Mexican-style cheese, queso fresco, state health officials said. The outbreak illustrates the dangers of consuming unpasteurized dairy products.

The Minnesota Department of Health (MDH), the Minnesota Department of Agriculture (MDA) and the City of Minneapolis have been investigating the raw.milk.queso frescooutbreak and the source of the raw milk used to make the cheese since the first cases were detected in late April.

MDH confirmed 18 cases of infection with the same strain of Salmonella. An additional seven cases of illness occurred among family members or other contacts of confirmed cases, but no laboratory specimens were available. The individuals became ill between March 28 and April 24. Of the 25 cases, 15 were hospitalized. All have recovered. Many cases reported eating unpasteurized queso fresco purchased or received from an individual who made the product in a private home. Investigators have determined that the individual made home deliveries and also may have sold the product on a street corner near the East Lake Street area of Minneapolis.

Anyone who may have purchased or received this product recently should not eat it but should throw it away.

Samples of unpasteurized queso fresco collected from the cheese maker were found to contain the same strain of Salmonella as the illnesses. Investigators determined that the milk used to make the cheese was purchased by the cheese maker from a Dakota County farm. Unpasteurized milk samples collected at the farm were also found to match the outbreak strain.

Dr. Heidi Kassenborg, director of MDA’s Dairy and Food Inspection Division, said the outbreak underscores the dangers of consuming unpasteurized dairy products. “It only takes a few bacteria to cause illness. Milking a cow is not a sterile process and even the cleanest dairy farms can have milk that is contaminated. That’s why pasteurization – or the heat treatment of milk to kill the harmful pathogens – is so important,” said Kassenborg.

Minnesota law allows consumers to purchase raw milk directly from the farm for their own consumption, but it may not be further distributed or sold. Additionally, cheese production facilities need to follow proper food safety laws and regulations, including licensure.

Dr. Carlota Medus said the outbreak may be over, as there are no suspect cases pending. However, it may still be possible to see additional cases that have not been reported yet from people who consumed cheese prior to health officials’ interventions, which occurred April 23-26.

While this particular outbreak may be over, MDA and MDH officials are concerned that this may not be an isolated incident: that there may be other instances of people buying foods like unpasteurized queso fresco prepared by neighbors, friends or family. “It’s important for people to be aware of the inherent risk of consuming any raw dairy product from any source,” Medus said. “We encourage people to think carefully about those risks and know that the risks are especially high for young children, pregnant women, the elderly and those with weakened immune systems.”

Raw milk farmer raided in Australia, UK to re-examine vending machine sales

As South Australia cracks down on raw milk sales, the UK Food Standards Agency had dropped charges against The Moo Man after he agreed to stop selling the milk on non-farm premises.

The Sussex Express explains London store Selfridges along with the star of The Moo Man, dairy farmer Stephen Hook had charges dropped while colbert.raw.milkofficials decide whether to change the law and allow raw milk sales in UK vending machines.

Not so in the state of South Australia, where it is illegal to sell raw milk, so consumers have adopted the North American tactic of buying shares in a cow.

David Basham, president of the South Australian Dairyfarmers Association told ABC News that as an industry they don’t want to see raw milk sold as they see the health risks as too great.

Geoff Raven from Biosecurity SA says that they have asked the dairy farmer involved to become an accredited farmer, who would then not be allowed to offer untreated milk to consumers.

Groundhog Day, Alaska Campylobacter-in-raw-milk version

Folks in Alaska must be undergoing their own kind of public health Groundhog Day – where the same day is relived with slight variations.

But unlike the Bill Murray movie, no matter how much the health types cajole, persuade, and act nice, things won’t change.

Ask Hugh Pennington.

Just days after a report implicated raw milk as the cause of 31 cases of campylobacteriosis, including four cases of reactive arthritis, in early 2013, bill.murray.groundhog.day_.storyAlaskan health profesionals had a paper published in the Journal of Food Protection documenting a 2011 outbreak of Campylobacter linked to … raw milk.

Snappy title, though: Sharing milk but not messages: Campylobacteriosis associated with consumption of raw milk from a cow-share program in Alaska, 2011.

Abstract below.

Alaska public and environmental health authorities investigated a cluster of campylobacteriosis cases among people who had consumed raw, unpasteurized milk obtained from a cow-share program in Alaska. Although raw milk is not permitted by law to be offered commercially, consumers can enter into cow-share agreements whereby they contribute funds for the upkeep of cows and in turn receive a share of the milk for their personal use. Laboratory testing of stool specimens collected from ill persons and from cows on the farm revealed an indistinguishable strain of Campylobacter. In this outbreak, numerous confirmed and suspected cases were not among cow shareholders; therefore, these individuals had not been advised of the potential health hazards associated with consumption of raw milk nor were they informed of the outbreak developments.

Journal of Food Protection®, Number 5, May 2013, pp. 744-918 , pp. 744-747(4)

Castrodale, L.J.; Gerlach, R.F.; Xavier, C.M.; Smith, B.J.; Cooper, M.P.; McLaughlin, J.B.

http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/iafp/jfp/2013/00000076/00000005/art00001

31 sick, 4 develop reactive arthritis; Campylobacter from raw milk, Alaska, Jan–Feb 2013

As noted in that World Health Organization report, the major sequelae of Campylobacteriosis are Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS), reactive arthritis (ReA) and irritable bowel syndrome (IBS).

GBS is a severe disease, requiring intensive care in some 20% of cases; case-fatality rates in high-income countries are between 3 and 10%. Globally, santa.barf.sprout.raw.milkapproximately one-third of GBS cases have been attributed to Campylobacter infection.

While it is difficult to determine the true extent of ReA, because of a lack of clear diagnostic and classification criteria, studies suggest that it occurs in 1–5% of those infected with Campylobacter. It has been estimated that 25% of ReA cases may go on to chronic spondyloarthropathy.

That’s exactly what happened in the Campylobacter-from-raw-milk outbreak in Alaska earlier this year.

On February 13, 2013, Alaska State Public Health Laboratory (ASPHL) notified the Alaska Section of Epidemiology (SOE) of a cluster of four C. coli isolates with an indistinguishable pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) pattern that was new to Alaska. All four isolates were grown from stool specimens collected in late January from ill Kenai Peninsula residents.

Patient interviews and other investigative work indicated that all four of the ill persons with PFGE-matching C. coli strains reported consuming raw (unpasteurized) milk within a few days of their illness onset. These initial interviews also led to additional case finding, primarily by way of ill persons reporting others they knew who were also ill with similar symptoms. While some of the persons napoleon milkwho were initially identified during this investigation were reluctant to say where their raw milk came from, four individuals reported that it came from Farm A, a cow-share farm on the Kenai Peninsula.

A confirmed case was defined as a laboratory-confirmed, PFGE-matched, C. coli infection diagnosed from January 1, 2013 onward. A clinical case was defined as an acute GI illness with self-reported diarrhea lasting ≥2 days in a person with exposure to Farm A raw milk within 10 days of illness onset. A secondary case was defined as an acute GI illness lasting ≥2 days in a person with close contact to a confirmed or clinical case within 10 days of illness onset.

On February 14, SOE notified the Office of the State Veterinarian (OSV) of the outbreak, and a joint press release and health advisory were issued on February 15.2 OSV immediately notified Farm A of the outbreak and requested a list of all active shareholders. Despite notification of the outbreak, Farm A continued to distribute raw milk to shareholders living in the Kenai Peninsula and in Anchorage.

During the week of February 18, two additional confirmed cases were reported—one of which was in a school-aged child who was hospitalized for 4 days with fevers, abdominal pain, rash, and acute reactive arthritis involving the wrists, ankles, knees, and hips. On February 22, an updated health advisory describing new developments in the outbreak was issued.3 On February 22, Farm A provided SOE with an incomplete shareholder list, which lacked contact information for the majority of shareholders. Calls were made to notify persons on the list about the outbreak and to identify additional cases.

In total, 31 cases were identified during the investigation. Ill persons ranged in age from 7 months to 72 years (median: 10 years). Three children and one adult developed reactive arthritis lasting a minimum of 6 weeks. Two persons were colbert.raw.milkhospitalized. All ill persons were Kenai Peninsula residents who either personally consumed Farm A raw milk within 10 days of illness onset (n=29) or met the secondary case definition (n=2).

Environmental Investigation

On February 22, OSV and SOE toured Farm A and collected cow feces, milk, and other environmental samples. Steps where the milk could be contaminated (from collection to bottling) were reviewed with the farmer, and the inherent risk of bacterial contamination of unpasteurized milk was discussed. The outbreak strain of C. coli was not isolated from the samples collected at the farm that day; however, three different strains of C. jejuni were isolated from cow manure, and Listeria monocytogenes grew from a raw milk sample.

This large outbreak of C. coli infection on the Kenai Peninsula was caused by consumption of Farm A raw milk. While this outbreak appears to be over, additional campylobacteriosis cases could still be identified at any time as Campylobacter species were identified from Farm A manure during the environmental investigation. Furthermore, this is the second outbreak of campylobacteriosis associated with consumption of raw milk distributed by an Alaskan cow-share operation in the past 2 years. These outbreaks are an unfortunate reminder of the inherent risks associated with raw milk consumption, and underscore the importance of pasteurization.

It is not surprising that the C. coli outbreak strain was not isolated from the environmental samples, as Campylobacter bacteria are difficult to isolate from the environment, they are shed intermittently in cow manure, and the farm visit occurred weeks after the outbreak peaked. Incidentally, L. monocytogenes—a bacteria that can cause life-threatening meningitis—was isolated from Farm A milk; no listeriosis cases were reported during the outbreak.

Finally, four (13%) ill persons developed reactive arthritis, a painful form of inflammatory arthritis that sometimes occurs in reaction to a bacterial infection and can persist for up to 12 months. These cases underscore the fact that Campylobacter infection can lead to prolonged adverse health consequences.

Raw milk sickened scores despite inspections

The majority of those sickened in raw milk outbreaks is children under 10-years-old. And there’s good immunological reasons for that. If adults want to take the risk with raw milk, they will, just like with cigarettes and alcohol. But parents generally don’t have a scotch and smoke with their 4-year-olds.

That’s what I told Karen Rowan of My Health News Daily in her report about a report appearing in Clinical Infectious Diseases, summarizing a Jan. 2012 campylobacter outbreak linked to raw milk that sickened 148 people in four states.

The dairy that sold the milk had a permit for selling unpasteurized milk, and had passed all inspections. The farm was among the largest sellers of unpasteurized colbert.raw.milkmilk in the state.

The dairy also tested its own milk for E. coli bacteria more often than was required. The vast majority of the sick people drank the milk before its “best by” date.

The only deficiencies that investigators found were that a mechanical milk bottle capper was broken, so employees had capped the bottles by hand, and that the water used to clean equipment was cooler than recommended (110 to 120 degrees Fahrenheit, instead of 160 to 170 degrees F).

But these issues were “minimal,” and this campylobacter outbreak demonstrates “the ongoing hazards of unpasteurized dairy products.”

Douglas Powell, a professor of food safety at Kansas State University advises that raw milk not be given to children. “As adults, you’re free to choose. But don’t give it to your kids.”

The people sickened in the outbreak ranged in age from 2 to 74, the report said. Typically, campylobacter infections cause diarrhea, abdominal pain and fever that last about a week, and most people get better on their own. In the outbreak, 10 people were hospitalized.

The dairy immediately suspended unpasteurized milk sales when it was informed of the outbreak.

The researchers recommended that state officials consider more regulation of unpasteurized milk, such as monthly pathogen testing.

21 now sick; Campylobacter outbreak traced to Alaskan raw milk

The state health department has traced the source of the campylobacter outbreak that has infected now more than 21 people back to Peninsula Dairy, a dairy farm in Kasilof on the Kenai Peninsula; two people have been hospitalized.

The farm operates a cow-share program. The milk is distributed to shareholders throughout the Kenai Peninsula, in Anchorage, and in Sitka. There is at least one colbert.raw.milksecondary case of an infant who became ill after having close contact with a laboratory-confirmed case.

The Peninsula Clarion reports tate veterinarian Bob Gerlach and Donna Fearey, a nurse epidemiologist for the state, on Tuesday inspected Peninsula Dairy, owned by Kevin Byers. Gerlach said they saw no problems with Byers’ operation.

“In comparison to most dairies, he’s doing a very pretty good job,” Gerlach said.

He said Byers had modern and clean equipment and his cows were healthy and well-fed.

In a 2011 outbreak, 18 people were stricken with Campylobacter that was eventually traced back to a farm owned by Byers’ brother in the Matanuska Valley.

The campylobacter infection was of a different strain, however, and Gerlach said connecting the two outbreaks would be inappropriate.

The department cannot close Byers’ farm as cow-share programs are legal, McLaughlin said. The direct sale of raw milk is, however, illegal, he said.

18 now sick; Campylobacter linked to raw milk in Alaska outbreak

The Alaska Department of Health and Social Services says that 18 people have now been identified with Campylobacter associated with raw-milkconsuming raw milk distributed by a Kenai-based cow-share program.

Two required hospitalization.

All probable and confirmed cases have been linked to consumption of raw milk from a farm on the Kenai Peninsula that operates a cow-share program. The milk is distributed to shareholders throughout the Kenai Peninsula, in Anchorage, and in Sitka. There is at least one secondary case of an infant who became ill after having close contact with a laboratory-confirmed case.

4 sick; Campylobacter linked to raw milk in Alaska outbreak

alaskapublic.org reports the Alaska State Department of Health is investigating an outbreak of a foodborne illness linked to raw milk. Officials have confirmed four cases of Campylobacter infection in people who drank raw milk on the Kenai Peninsula.

Dr. Brian Yablon is a medical epidemiologist with the state. He says the cases colbert.raw.milkhave all been identified by the state lab in the last three weeks:

“When they looked at these strains, they found that the four specimens were all exactly the same type, so that is consistent with a cluster of illnesses and when we found out additional information it seemed that all of the people who developed the infection had consumed raw milk or unpasteurized milk in the proceeding several days before they got sick,” Yablon said.

The state is still working to identify the source of the raw milk. A farmer named Kevin Byers in Kasilof distributes raw milk to families around the state. He did not agree to a recorded interview, but said he doesn’t know if his milk is responsible for the outbreak. He says his customers drink his milk for the perceived health benefits. According to a recent newspaper article, Byers has 150 customers as far away as Sitka.

Selling raw milk is illegal in Alaska. But farmers have found ways to do it legally.

A similar outbreak of Campylobacter bacteria was traced to a Mat-Su Valley farmer in 2011. There were 18 people with probable or confirmed illness in that outbreak. That operation has since gone out of business.

Finland to OK raw milk sales?

Sales of raw milk have been strictly regulated in Finland due to the risk of bacterial infections, but now the Ministry of Agriculture is preparing an ordinance based on the belief that no restrictions should be placed on milk sales, as long as producers and consumers carefully follow the directives handed down by authorities.

In June, several people fell ill after drinking raw milk bought directly from a farm in south-western Finland. They included a four-year-old who was hospitalized in intensive care.